logoalt Hacker News

dijityesterday at 4:59 PM2 repliesview on HN

Yes, I paid for Windows 11. It came bundled with the £1,900 laptop I bought. The fact that the licence cost is hidden in the hardware price doesn't make it free.

And even if it were free, which it isn't, that still wouldn't justify ads. Android is free. Linux is free. Neither ships with gambling app promotions in the system UI.

Microsoft made $20 billion in Windows revenue last year. They're not a scrappy startup looking for alternative monetisation. The ads exist because they can get away with it, not because they need to.


Replies

rmunntoday at 5:47 AM

> The fact that the licence cost is hidden in the hardware price doesn't make it free.

I appreciate manufacturers who make this obvious. For example, when I bought the Framework laptop I'm using now, the OS choices were preinstalled Windows 11 (default selection), preinstalled Linux (-$150), none/I'll install my own (-$150). Made it clear exactly what I would have been paying for the Windows license if I had chosen Windows.

Gander5739yesterday at 11:37 PM

Many variants of Android ship with ads, particularly on cheaper phones. Xiaomi phones for instance.

show 1 reply