logoalt Hacker News

sejjetoday at 5:33 PM1 replyview on HN

> A Trump-appointed Federal judge clearly did not find that excuse compelling.

A Trump-appointed judge set a hearing about a situation where he was told a US citizen was being deported. I would expect any judge to care about that, regardless of who appointed them. Because we don't actually deport US citizens, it turns out.

> The same org claimed Alex Pretti was an assassin who was attempting to massacre ICE, remember. They lie; that's a matter of public record.

The same org that is claiming what?

> https://nipnlg.org/...

They didn't allege in that document that it was coerced. They allege that they didn't give them enough options to contact family etc. She had an option to leave the child in the US.

> "the officer threatened Julia that Jade would be immediately sent to a foster home in the United States if Julia did not write a note stating that Jade would be deported to Honduras with her."

This shows that the child going to Honduras was a choice by the mother. Under duress? Sure, she's getting deported. Tough choice. But she made it, not the government.

> That's directly contradicted by your link; "the case was closed without a ruling on the merits".

No it's not. What, you think the judge never saw the piece of paper? You think active cases are closed without involving the judge?

> I have no difficulty at all finding this case; I replied to your comment about five minutes after you posted it.

Sure, but it didn't fit the criteria. This US citizen wasn't deported by the government. Their mother was, and she chose to take the child with her.


Replies

ceejayoztoday at 8:24 PM

> A Trump-appointed judge set a hearing about a situation where he was told a US citizen was being deported.

He's quoted as having a "strong suspicion" that a US citizen was deported.

> The same org that is claiming what?

DHS claims it was a voluntary deportation. But DHS also claimed Alex Pretti was an assassin. They're simply not credible.

> They didn't allege in that document that it was coerced.

I directly quoted it. Here it is again:

"When Julia objected, the officer threatened Julia that Jade would be immediately sent to a foster home in the United States if Julia did not write a note stating that Jade would be deported to Honduras with her."

> You think active cases are closed without involving the judge?

Again, "the case was closed without a ruling on the merits".

> Sure, but it didn't fit the criteria.

Given the above, and your other comments on incidents even Trump, Miller, and Noem are walking back their statements on, I'm not certain you're really reading anything.

show 1 reply