logoalt Hacker News

Analemma_yesterday at 6:56 PM9 repliesview on HN

> I have a credit card with HSBC: you know, the bank with virtue-signalling multiculturalism in their ads.

Was this opening sentence necessary? It is not germane at all to the rest of the article. Ironically, it is itself virtue-signalling (for some definition of virtue), just to a different audience.


Replies

CodesInChaosyesterday at 8:08 PM

It doesn't even link to an ad, it links to a weird parody attempt of the ad on the same site as the article. Which makes little sense for people unfamiliar with the original ad it parodies.

enlightensyesterday at 7:19 PM

I took the use of "virtue signalling" to be an intentional jab at HSBC given everything

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Controversies

show 1 reply
throwaway902984yesterday at 7:03 PM

My first instinct was to close the article as I didn't want to read a Republican virtue signaling to his audience. I wonder if they were trying to sound Republican?

The article itself is a nice, well interesting, dive into the topic; kinda unfortunate.

show 5 replies
swiftcoderyesterday at 8:04 PM

> just to a different audience

And apparently not targeted all that well, since half the comments here think it is a right-wing (anti-multiculturalism) sentiment, and the other half a left-wing (anti-corporate-reputation-laundering) sentiment.

arduanikayesterday at 7:54 PM

Not only a distraction, but also fails to distinguish HSBC from pretty much any other bank, so the "the" comes off as crankish and aggrieved.

rjswyesterday at 7:54 PM

People used to bank with Barclays to register their support for Apartheid in South Africa.

bstsbyesterday at 7:00 PM

precisely this. it sort of put me off an otherwise excellent article