logoalt Hacker News

popalchemistyesterday at 9:09 PM1 replyview on HN

Sales tax is one of the most UNFAIR, being a flat tax, it affects people in indirect proportion to their wealth (poorest hit hardest, proportionately).


Replies

epolanskiyesterday at 10:45 PM

This is the only counter argument, and in fact the consensus is that they are the fairest (they tax consumption rather than production, we tend to tax producing wealth more than spending it) if you offer rebates or lower them on essentials (bread, milk, eggs, healthcare).

They also have the effect that everybody has to pay them, including tax evaders, tax loophole abusers, criminals with undeclared incomes, etc, everybody has to pay it.

But yes, without offering sales tax rebates or with taxing essentials then your argument is true and they become less fair.

Albeit, the elephant in the room is always the definition of fairness itself.

show 1 reply