logoalt Hacker News

theodrictoday at 12:10 AM1 replyview on HN

> Also you should be keeping those CAD and games up to date

Not OP, but why? I have a perpetual license and a 12-year-old copy of a corpo CAD package and it works fine. I see no reason to compulsively update something that's feature-complete and functional.

Updates break shit or make shit worse for me all the time. See: Windows 11, macOS Tahoe, and KDE next year when they drop my working X11 session and expect me to use busted-ass Wayland that's missing functionality I use daily.

Why do I need updates? "Security?" I'm not exactly a nation-state hacking target. I don't run random pirated software. I'm firewalled to hell, and behind CGNAT on Starlink. I'll keep my browser up to date, fine, but I'm still running -esr.


Replies

gerdesjtoday at 12:40 AM

"that's feature-complete and functional."

I get where you are coming from. That was my stance roughly 20 years ago too. I also note that you are quite clearly not daft!

You and I have different "jobs". I worry about thousands of systems on many sites, one of which is my home. I'm an IT consultant and am the managing director of my company. I think you are an engineer, perhaps retired ("12-year-old copy of a corpo CAD package and it works fine")

If Solidworks, Catia, AutoCAD or whatever (?) works then fine. You might like to firewall off whichever vendor's website/security systems might want to stop a 12 year old copy of a corpo CAD from working if it isn't licensed. It probably is because all of the above generally need a license service.

I worry about many 1000s of PCs and I think updates, patches etc are a good idea. If you are an engineer, then you will have to do your own "deploy, fix issues" cycle. IT is just the same.

show 1 reply