logoalt Hacker News

coryrcyesterday at 6:00 PM4 repliesview on HN

First, it's still the automobile's fault.

At least it was already slowed down to 17 mph to start. Remember that viral video of some Australian in a pickup ragdolling a girl across the road? Most every comment is "well he was going the speed limit no fault for him!" No asshole, you hit someone. It's your fault. He got zero charges and the girl was seriously injured.


Replies

WheatMillingtonyesterday at 6:39 PM

You seem to be implying that there are no circumstances in which a vehicle can hit a pedestrian and the driver not be at fault... which is absurd.

show 3 replies
fennecbuttyesterday at 6:27 PM

You mean the Aussie one where the guy was going an appropriate speed for the area and when the cops arrived the parents and their neighbors LIED TO THE POLICE and said he was hooning down the road at excess speed and hit the kid? And that he was only saved from prison by having a dash cam that proved the lies to be lies? That one?

That logic is utter bs, if someone jumps out when you're travelling at an appropriate speed and you do your best to stop then that's all that can be done. Otherwise by your logic the only safe speed is 0.

show 1 reply
dilyevskyyesterday at 7:18 PM

That’s not how fault works

foxglacieryesterday at 10:38 PM

It's not the drivers fault when they hit a kid who darts out in front of them and they had no time to react and weren't doing anything illegal like speeding.

show 1 reply