logoalt Hacker News

hshdhdhj4444last Friday at 5:28 PM2 repliesview on HN

Animals do a whole bunch of things to other animals we wouldn’t consider acceptable.

Cannibalism, eating your young, rape, etc.

I’m not sure why killing for food is the one place we should choose to define our values and ethics based on what animals in the wild do.


Replies

robcohenlast Friday at 6:31 PM

The problem I have with being vegetarian is that you can't prove that it's actually healthier, because the current state of dietary science is pretty poor.

Even if you could, you would also need to explain all of the evolutionary problems that could come from some humans going vegetarian while others don't.

What if being vegetarian makes you smaller and weaker physically (perhaps the case in some vegetarian countries now). If you had the answer, and it was clear a diet consisting of vegetables causes reduction in physical size, then I have to ask:

Would you want your kids to be shorter and physically weaker than you are?

show 4 replies
card_zerolast Friday at 6:41 PM

Conversely, I'm not sure why we shouldn't limit our tender feelings to the individual animals we personally relate to. Values are based on other values, and equality is based on freedom of thought and the value of knowledge. Being kind to animals is about humans really, I think.