logoalt Hacker News

SilverElfinyesterday at 10:20 PM6 repliesview on HN

Taxing bullion is absurd - it’s not a product but more like currency or a placeholder of money you already have. What other taxes are they passing when you say “frenzy”?


Replies

jfengelyesterday at 10:25 PM

Why is it more like a currency than any other object? It's not negotiable currency or legal tender.

People buy it and sell it. I don't see any difference between bullion, iron ore, frozen concentrated orange juice, and Pokemon cards. You buy a thing, you pay the sales tax.

show 1 reply
WalterBrighttoday at 4:02 AM

> What other taxes are they passing when you say “frenzy”?

https://www.ballardspahr.com/insights/alerts-and-articles/20...

It's incomplete, it doesn't list the gold tax.

robotresearcheryesterday at 10:38 PM

Gold hasn't been money since 1971.

dmos62yesterday at 10:26 PM

Is taxing investment absurd?

show 3 replies
loglogyesterday at 11:17 PM

Wealth tax is the best type of tax, because it incentivizes productive activities against speculation. It should be levied on a continuous basis rather than on transaction basis though, which is just basic numerical analysis.

show 1 reply