logoalt Hacker News

jfengeltoday at 2:26 AM1 replyview on HN

The converse need not hold. Cognition implies existence; it is sufficient but not necessary. Plenty of things exist without thinking.

(And that's not what the Cogito means in the first place. It's a statement about knowledge: I think therefore it is a fact that I am. Descartes is using it as the basis of epistemology; he has demonstrated from first principles that at least one thing exists.)


Replies

bigbadfelinetoday at 4:23 AM

I know the trivialities. I didn't intend to make a general or formal statement, we're talking about people. In a competitive world, those who've been reduced to idiocracy won't survive, AI not only isn't going to help them, it will be used against them.

> Plenty of things exist without thinking.

Existence in an animal farm isn't human existence.