logoalt Hacker News

subhobrotoyesterday at 6:04 PM1 replyview on HN

> but if you don't put the work to understand things you'll always be behind people that know at least with a bird eye view what's happening.

Depends. You might end up going quite far without even opening up the hood of a car even when you drive the car everyday and depend on it for your livelihood.

If you're the kind that likes to argue for a good laugh, you might say "well, I don't need to know how my car works as long as the engineer who designed it does or the mechanic who fixes it does" - and this is accurate but it's also accurate not everyone ended up being either the engineer or the mechanic. It's also untrue that if it turned out it would be extremely valuable to you to actually learn how the car worked, you wouldn't put in the effort to do so and be very successful at it.

All this talk about "you should learn something deeply so you can bank on it when you will need it" seems to be a bit of a hoarding disorder.

Given the right materials, support and direction, most smart and motivated people can learn how to get competent at something that they had no clue about in the past.

When it comes to smart and motivated people, the best drop out of education because they find it unproductive and pedantic.


Replies

thomasfortesyesterday at 6:25 PM

Yes, you can and I know just enough of cars to not be scammed by people, but not to know how the whole engine works, and I also don't think that you should learn everything that you can learn, there's no time for that, that's why I made the bird view comment.

My argument is that when you have at least a basic knowledge of how things work (be it as a musician, a mechanical engineer or a scientist) you are in a much better place to know what you want/need.

That said, smart and motivated people thrive if they are given the conditions to thrive, and I believe that physical interfaces have way less friction than digital interfaces, turning a knob is way less work than clicking a bunch of menus to set up a slider.

If I were to summarize what I think about AI it would be something like "Let it help you. Do not let it think for you"

My issue is not with people using AI as a tool, bit with people delegating anything that would demand any kind of effort to AI