logoalt Hacker News

appreciatorBusyesterday at 11:47 PM2 repliesview on HN

It is possible for the human species to exist without cigarette smoke, and doubtless for at least part of our history it did not exist.

It is not possible for the human species (or any form of mortal biological life) to exist without children.

If you want to try to define the latter observation of reality as “abnormal”, fill your boots.


Replies

stevagetoday at 5:20 AM

There are lot of holes in your argument:

- civilisation is currently more at risk from overpopulation than depopulation

- just because children need to exist doesn't imply they need to exist in apartment buildings

- just because children exist doesn't imply that they need to play outdoors on balconies

- just because children exist doesn't imply that there can't be limits on how much noise they can make, and when

etc etc

show 1 reply
its_ubuntutoday at 2:17 AM

> It is possible for the human species to exist without cigarette smoke

Yeah, and it's possible for it to exist without whatever pleasures you enjoy too that I don't approve of. I'm sure I can invent some twisted, self serving reasoning to justify why your activity should be banned, as I don't like it, and my judgment is better than yours.

> It is not possible for the human species (or any form of mortal biological life) to exist without children.

No, but some people's kids we could do without. Especially the ones who want to ban everything.