logoalt Hacker News

wtcactusyesterday at 11:46 AM1 replyview on HN

> Were you working at a food bank in the rich neighbourhood of a rich city of a rich country?

Yes, I was working in food bank in a rich country. That's what all capitalist European countries and USA (you know, the ones where you claimed above people didn't have food), are: rich!

> You have all the exact same talking points of the people who were born lucky and never really struggled,

Yes, I was born lucky: My parents were hardworking blue collar workers receiving the minimum wage for most of my childhood and guess what: they still managed to provide me all that was needed and put money aside for themselves so not to depend on any handouts. So, yes, I lived a very lucky privileged life that anyone that lives in a capitalist country and is not afraid to work can also have.


Replies

latexryesterday at 12:36 PM

> you know, the ones where you claimed above people didn't have food

You are being dishonest. That was not the claim.

> My parents were hardworking blue collar workers

Did they pull themselves by their bootstraps? You’re engaging in what is called the hard work fallacy.

> guess what: they still managed to provide me all that was needed and put money aside for themselves so not to depend on any handouts.

What year was that again? Want to go check some housing prices and the wage gap between now and then? You sure were lucky one of your parents didn’t get sick with a fatal chronic illness as you were growing up, burdening the other with ever rising health costs which bankrupted them through no fault of their own. Tell me, were any of them ever racially profiled and were thrown in jail on a bullshit charge, making them lose their job and fall into ever increasing debt?

I have no doubt you faced some hardship. But make no mistake, you had advantages that many people did not have, and it was down to blind luck. Believing that other people deserve what they get because they are lazy is a selfish view that cuts your nose to spite your face. Your parents and yourself shouldn’t have faced any hardships, and neither should the people living in poverty now. You’re blaming the people with no money instead of the people hoarding all of it, as they get ever richer.

I’ll say it again: Capitalism’s most outstanding feature is that no matter how much mistreatment there is, we can always count on someone coming out to ask for more. That’s exactly what you’re doing. Break the cycle.