logoalt Hacker News

Terrettayesterday at 2:09 PM5 repliesview on HN

Don't tell me I'm not allowed to click buttons you put in my face.

Any jurisdiction where this is supposedly illegal, it hasn't been court tested seriously.*

Per your link: "What you're describing is essentially the extension AdNauseam. So far they have not had any legal troubles, but they technically could." That stance or an assertion it's not illegal is consistent throughout the thread, provided you aren't clicking your own ads.

"The industry" thinks you shouldn't be allowed to fast forward your own VCR through an ad either. They can take a flying .. lesson.

* Disclaimer: I don't know if that's true, but it sounds true.


Replies

gruezyesterday at 2:34 PM

>Don't tell me I'm not allowed to click buttons you put in my face.

No, the illegal-ness doesn't come from the clicking, it comes from the fact you're clicking with the intention of defrauding someone. That's also why filling out a credit card application isn't illegal, but filling out the same credit card application with phony details is.

show 5 replies
y-curiousyesterday at 2:12 PM

Telling me this is illegal has made me want to download it more. “IT IS ILLEGAL TO ATTACK THIS NONCONSENSUAL SPAM SIR”

show 1 reply
dhruv3006yesterday at 2:34 PM

Whats the case in EU? Any idea?

WarmWashyesterday at 2:55 PM

>Don't tell me I'm not allowed to click buttons you put in my face.

To be fair, you put it in your own face, by visiting the site...

show 1 reply
direwolf20yesterday at 2:33 PM

You're not clicking the button, you're sending a known fraudulent request saying the ad was clicked, when the ad was not clicked

show 2 replies