logoalt Hacker News

mlsuyesterday at 9:07 PM2 repliesview on HN

Has there ever been a situation where taking away parking has lead to traffic dropping?

I've heard this, but I've never seen an example in practice. It seems like making things more walkable and bikeable, at the expense of cars, always increases foot-traffic, with no exception.


Replies

CalRoberttoday at 5:41 AM

I think what you’re referring to is traffic evaporation. But that’s sometimes referring to road capacity more than parking

bluGillyesterday at 9:15 PM

Yes, though I can't recall enough details that I could help you search.

Basically anytime it is tried in the suburbs where nobody is walking now nothing changes. When a lot of people are already walking you can increase traffic by getting rid of cars.

Details matter, most of the places people take aware cars are already dense areas and they tell you about it. However in a few cases someone who hasn't understood the context tried to apply a lesson it doesn't apply and it fails.