logoalt Hacker News

alex_youngyesterday at 10:07 PM7 repliesview on HN

Data centers in space are a hilariously bad idea. Where would the heat go? This idea is like the opposite of liquid cooling.


Replies

gordonhartyesterday at 10:13 PM

Shocked to see SpaceX buy the datacenter in space meme. Where does the power come from? Where does the heat go? Why add (high) launch costs to your buildout capex? Why add radiation as another risk factor to your already-unreliable GPUs? Am I missing something fundamental here...?

show 1 reply
brightballyesterday at 10:11 PM

Aside from Elon Musk, there are a few other people with a lot of capital aiming to do the same thing. That means, either they are all wrong (possible) or this problem has been solved somehow and the solution itself is not public.

Google and Amazon are doing the same thing. Maybe it is a moonshot (pun intended), but Musk is hardly alone in the push.

https://www.wsj.com/tech/bezos-and-musk-race-to-bring-data-c...

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/01/technology/space-data-cen...

ppponeyesterday at 10:12 PM

Not to mention the huge issues of cosmic rays. Sure, if the lifespan of the satellite is expected to be low, then maybe tolerable. But even then, how would this be financially viable?

googlemeyesterday at 10:11 PM

I didn't say it was a good idea, just that if Musk perceives it's a good idea then it makes sense why he would want to combine the two businesses.

show 1 reply
falloutxyesterday at 10:33 PM

Only a person who is high as a kite can think thats a good idea.

Hikikomoriyesterday at 10:10 PM

Some guy on hacker news argued they could just use radiators.

show 1 reply
gspryesterday at 10:11 PM

Indeed. But it's also a hilariously Musky idea! Some moderate technical competence paired with sociopathy and an ego orders of magnitude too big, and voila, you get Cybertrucks, Hyperloops, Neuralinks, Teslabots, datacenters in space, and all the other garbage the man spews.

I cannot wait for him to one day be hit in the face by reality.

show 1 reply