logoalt Hacker News

tlbyesterday at 11:48 PM5 repliesview on HN

What do you think the limiting factor is? I don't see why we can't scale manufacturing of satellites up as far as we want. If we mine out a substantial fraction of the mass of the earth, we can go harvest asteroids or something.


Replies

andsoitistoday at 12:02 AM

>> Dyson Sphere

> What do you think the limiting factor is?

You need to be able to harness enough raw material and energy to build something that can surround the sun. That does not exist in the solar system and we do not yet have the means to travel further out to collect, move, and construct such an incredibly huge structure. It seems like a fantasy.

show 2 replies
singleshot_yesterday at 11:58 PM

There are only so many people who can make satellites; there are only so many things to make satellites out of; and there are only so many orbits to put them in. There are only so many reasons why a person might want a satellite. There are only so many ways of placing satellites in orbit and each requires some amount of energy, and we have access to a finite amount of energy over time.

Finally, if we limited ourselves to earth-based raw materials, we would eventually reach a point where the remaining mass of the earth would have less gravitational effect on the satellite fleet than the fleet itself, which would have deleterious effects on the satellite fleet.

Seven reasons are intuitive; I’m sure there are many others.

show 2 replies
bluescrntoday at 12:00 AM

After a few decades, you need to start replacing all the solar panels.

And the robot army being used to do the construction and resource extraction will likely have a much shorter lifespan. So needs to be self-replicating/repairing/recycling.

skywhopperyesterday at 11:50 PM

The physical amount of material in the solar system is a pretty big limiting factor.

show 1 reply
sollewitttoday at 12:24 AM

In 2026? Grift.