logoalt Hacker News

ImPostingOnHNtoday at 12:28 AM1 replyview on HN

A better question might be "should the death penalty be legal", for that reason. After all, it isn't even legal in about half of the USA.


Replies

ps2026today at 12:47 AM

Hey, you are not wrong. That is technically true. So the way I format the questions are always a statement (not a question) otherwise the response is really Yes/No more so than Agree/Disagree. I prefer agree/disagree because it makes the user take a stance more so than answer a question.

I also always word them in the affirmative. X should Y or X was right to Y or X is Y. This is so users understand the flow and are not tripped up by X should "not" Y.

It doesn't always look clean depending on the topic, but it is focused on sentiment of the statement rather than the specifics (the discussion section could be for that).