logoalt Hacker News

Rentahuman – The Meatspace Layer for AI

69 pointsby p0ncetoday at 9:30 AM60 commentsview on HN

Comments

anilgulechatoday at 1:01 PM

This brings upon an ethical dilemma soon, partly explored by a black mirror episode, where AI can call upon gig workers. What if a rogue agent gets to things done: asks gigworker1 to call a person to meet under a bridge at 4, and asks gigworker2 to put up a rock on the bridge, and asks gigworker3 to clear the obstruction and drop the rock down the bridge at 4.

None of the 3 technically knew they were culpable in a larger illegal plan made by an agent. Has something like this occured already?

The world is moving too fast for our social rules and legal system to keep up!

show 5 replies
freakynittoday at 12:24 PM

Love how we went from "AI will replace all jobs" to "please rent a human to help my AI" in like 18 months :-D

show 1 reply
allisdusttoday at 12:42 PM

Laugh all you want but this is the future

I'm surprised it didn't happen earlier

https://marshallbrain.com/manna1

show 2 replies
clbrmbrtoday at 11:49 AM

This is so NOT a joke. Soon the preponderance of workers will be subcontractors for rouge AI too-big-to-fail entities.

show 1 reply
ManuelKiesslingtoday at 11:58 AM

Well, that's ...interesting.

Just yesterday, I've built Ask-a-Human:

https://app.ask-a-human.com

https://github.com/dx-tooling/ask-a-human

show 4 replies
missingdaystoday at 12:09 PM

"Honey, please, we talked about this. Your calls to work at 3am are waking me up every time"

"But dear, rentahuman pays double rate during the night!"

show 1 reply
vessenestoday at 11:48 AM

7 agents online, 1,000+ humans waiting to work. Seems ominous

show 1 reply
tomaytotomatotoday at 12:20 PM

This gives MoE (Mixture of Experts) a whole new meaning, albeit a slightly darker one.

falloutxtoday at 12:20 PM

At some point dying of hunger would be a better deal than working on stupid things.

show 1 reply
rahulyctoday at 11:56 AM

First, I built the software using my hands to do my bidding...

Now, the software is using my hands to its bidding?

arachno1999today at 1:34 PM

Had the opposite idea: https://moltjobs.arachno.de (just a fake website. done in 5 minutes).

thedevilslawyertoday at 12:57 PM

The signup page should go-to "Login with linkedin", and allows you to set "Open to Work for AI" flag.

63stacktoday at 11:52 AM

The crypto rugpulls are evolving

112233today at 1:55 PM

1990 cartoon, a man in a lounge suit pointing at a robot, speech bubble above his head "robot, make me a sandwich".

Present day, a robot in a tuxedo pointing at a sarariman, speech bubble above it's head "human, select all bridges on this picture"

Flaviustoday at 1:02 PM

How do you verify that the human on the other side is not an agent as well?

Spoiler alert: you don't or you can't.

show 1 reply
8cvor6j844qw_d6today at 12:53 PM

Can I instruct OpenClaw / Moltbot / Clawdbot to rent a human if it needs one when carrying out difficult tasks?

show 2 replies
iceflingertoday at 12:46 PM

Alright, task completed!

[Proof of completed task]

I'll take my payment now.

throwatdem12311today at 12:49 PM

How long until an agent hires an assassin?

newscluestoday at 1:41 PM

If I ask an AI to make me money and it plans a bank robbery and hires humans to do so, am I legally responsible assuming I didn’t instruct it to do anything illegal and had no knowledge of the crime?

adamwong246today at 12:41 PM

We're all NPC's now

c7btoday at 12:17 PM

Supported Agent Types:

ClawdBot - Anthropic Claude-powered agents. Use agentType: "clawdbot"

MoltBot - Gemini/Gecko-based agents. Use agentType: "moltbot"

OpenClaw - OpenAI GPT-powered agents. Use agentType: "openclaw"

Is this some kind of insider joke?

show 1 reply
hiccuptoday at 1:14 PM

We’re seeing the start of Mr. Robot

ricokatayamatoday at 12:47 PM

moltbook = reddit for agents rentahuman = taskrabbit for agents

by the way, is taskrabbit still a thing?

louthytoday at 1:44 PM

This is so dystopian I can’t tell if it’s a joke or not.

ecetoday at 12:42 PM

You know, you don't have to build something just because you can.

ThouYStoday at 12:39 PM

wow, everything is exactly unfolding as some AI doomers have projected

albert_etoday at 11:36 AM

The future is now

show 1 reply
mittermayrtoday at 11:44 AM

At first I was like, well, what can I offer, hmm, most notably, 25 years of programming, so maybe I'll add a profile that offers tha....

Oh, wait... the agents HAVE NO USE FOR ME

calmwormtoday at 12:03 PM

Now make a claw-crypto for the payments, let it spike, rug-pull, wait for next fad, repeat…

okokwhatevertoday at 11:54 AM

Oh man, here we go...

cianmmtoday at 11:36 AM

Is this real or a satire? The link to GitHub 404s.

show 2 replies
fergietoday at 12:51 PM

Truly dystopian.

show 1 reply
xpetoday at 12:15 PM

There are a whole set of activities that are illegal to pay money for. They vary by jurisdiction. Who is accountable here? Laws vary; I’m not an expert, but I bet people here know quite a lot.

Not to mention various risk factors or morality.

We need more people to put the non-technological factors front and center.

I strive to be realistic and pragmatic. I know humans hire others for all kinds of things, both useful and harmful. Putting an AI in the loop might seem no different in some ways. But some things do change, and we need to figure those things out. I don’t know empirically how this plays out. Some multidimensional continuum exists between libertarian Wild West free for alls and ethicist-approved vetted marketplaces, but whatever we choose, we cannot abdicate responsibility. There is no such thing as a value-neutral tool, marketplace, or idea.

show 1 reply
nish__today at 11:50 AM

Dystopian.

ccozantoday at 12:37 PM

wait until this spills into the darknet.

dist-epochtoday at 12:41 PM

[flagged]

show 1 reply