logoalt Hacker News

tokaiyesterday at 12:46 PM2 repliesview on HN

In what world is generating CSAM a speech issue? Its really doing a disservice to actual free speech issues to frame it was such.


Replies

direwolf20yesterday at 11:48 PM

if pictures are speech, then either CSAM is speech, or you have to justify an exception to the general rule.

CSAM is banned speech.

logicchainsyesterday at 12:51 PM

The point of banning real CSAM is to stop the production of it, because the production is inherently harmful. The production of AI or human generated CSAM-like images does not inherently require the harm of children, so it's fundamentally a different consideration. That's why some countries, notably Japan, allow the production of hand-drawn material that in the US would be considered CSAM.

show 4 replies