logoalt Hacker News

Terr_yesterday at 10:21 PM9 repliesview on HN

I'm convinced that >30% of this comes from ideas leaking out of fiction such as like Neuromancer, and percolating through the minds of wealthy people attracted to some of the concepts. Namely, the dream of being a hyper-wealthy dynasty, above any earthly government, controlling an extraterritorial Las Vegas Fiefdom In Space. (Which in the book, also hosted a powerful AI.)

Then they work backwards, trying to figure out some economic engine to make it happen. "Data centers" are (A) in-vogue for investment right now and (B) vaguely plausible, at least compared to having a space-casino.


Replies

mbb70yesterday at 10:44 PM

That's not fair! Sometimes the ideas come from Snow Crash, which gave us the Metaverse because Zuckerberg wanted to cut a guy in half with a katana from a motorcycle.

show 2 replies
digiowntoday at 2:50 AM

> above any earthly government

Anti satellite weapons are a thing. Besides, the more vulnerable part becomes you as a person rather than the equipment. There's no space colony yet, and even if there is, the supplies can be easily held hostage by an earthly government too.

dgxyzyesterday at 11:56 PM

I wouldn’t credit science fiction for much of this.

It appears to have come out of a crack pipe.

show 1 reply
fullsharkyesterday at 11:53 PM

This idea came from musk wanting to fold his X and xAI investments in with his (likely successful) spaceX IPO.

show 1 reply
scottyahtoday at 12:28 AM

I mean definitely, and they're not shy about admitting it. They see cool stuff in imagination-land, think it's cool, and work to make it a reality. Many people have worked to make the fantastical things shown in Star Trek.

threecheesetoday at 1:12 AM

Stole Grok from Heinlein. At least it’s a good heuristic for people-I-don’t-have-to-take-seriously.

show 1 reply
turtletontineyesterday at 10:34 PM

I’ve come to think of interviews with people like Sam Altman as “freestyle science fiction.” They’re just saying stuff off the top of their head. Like you say, that often entails vague ideas from other sci fi percolating up and out, with no consideration of if they actually make sense. And like most freestyle, it’s usually pretty bad.

show 1 reply
GuinansEyebrowstoday at 12:07 AM

well, don't forget, freeside's initial moneymaker was a datahaven for less-reputable banks!

lofaszvanitttoday at 12:04 AM

A lot more. Everyone is chasing scifi ideas, ridiculous. This shows that even people with high IQ lack fantasy/imagination and creativity. They are intelligent robots.

So whenever I see here or anywhere else that your ideas mean nothing I just laugh at it. Of course, these come from people who are bland, doesn't have any imagination and they are not creative at all at all, but they have brute force, which is money.

show 1 reply