logoalt Hacker News

GCUMstlyHarmlstoday at 5:58 AM2 repliesview on HN

I can't help but imagine training horses vs training cats. One of them is rewarding, a pleasure, beautiful to see, the other is frustrating, leaves you with a lot of scratches and ultimately both of you "agreeing" on a marginal compromise.


Replies

lambdaonetoday at 10:30 AM

Right now vibe coding is more like training cats. You are constantly pushing against the model's tendency to produce its default outputs regardless of your directions. When those default outputs are what you want - which they are in many simple cases of effectively English-to-code translation with memorized lookup - it's great. When they are not, you might as well write the code yourself and at least be able to understand the code you've generated.

show 1 reply
KptMarchewatoday at 11:59 AM

I've never seen horse that scratches you.