logoalt Hacker News

johnfntoday at 2:58 AM2 repliesview on HN

Are you really claiming that there isn't a machine in existence that can code? And that that is never possible?


Replies

kalterdevtoday at 4:21 AM

It can code in an autocomplete sense. In the serious sense, if we don’t distinguish between code and thought, it can’t.

Observe that modern coding agents rely heavily on heuristics. LLM excels at training datasets, at analyzing existing knowledge, but it can’t generate new knowledge on the same scale, its thinking (a process of identification and integration) is severely limited on the conscious level (context window), where being rational is most valuable.

Because it doesn’t have volition, it cannot choose to be logical and not irrational, it cannot commit to attaining the full non-contradictory awareness of reality. That’s why I said “never.”

show 2 replies
wavemodetoday at 3:48 AM

I think "quite", "well", and "now" are the objectionable parts of the quote.