logoalt Hacker News

pinnochiotoday at 4:25 AM1 replyview on HN

I'm not sure what you mean by 'metaphysical' here, but I get the impression that you're dismissively trivializing real psychological problems by using that word.

An improvement in material conditions does not straightforwardly make up for these problems. What if they cause the viewer to commit suicide, or be so distraught they can no longer continue to work? People who do this work tend not to be able to do it for very long.

You also seem to be evaluating this by taking the current order of things for granted, as if it were not possible for this kind of thing to not be necessary in the first place. Quite a stunted imagination.


Replies

simianwordstoday at 4:32 AM

_you_ don’t know what it means to be under material poverty.

Look up farmer suicides in India an you can understand how material poverty leads to even more suicides statistically.

These people don’t even have food to sustain. One of the biggest problems is that poor people in India have low IQ because they literally can’t afford food with vitamins.

Low IQ leads to irrational decisions, low productivity and they get equal vote so they vote in idiots that slow progress.

These jobs are the best deal for overall progress of India. Sure they have to struggle in the middle but at least they have good food on the plate. Some safety net to make long term decisions and vote for better leaders.

You wouldn’t get it. You would just show concern. But Indians have to deal with the problems.

show 1 reply