logoalt Hacker News

bearjawsyesterday at 8:35 PM8 repliesview on HN

The downfall of Heroku should be studied, they had lightning in a bottle and blew it.

Salesforce acquired them and just let it die, baffling.


Replies

codegeekyesterday at 9:22 PM

Nothing to study. A common scenario when a mega corp acquires an incredibly successful startup and then lets it die. Happens more often than not. This is why I chuckle when I see an acquisition and the founders claim "Nothing is changing. We are not going anywhere" . There may be exceptions but the moment a hugely successful company like heroku gets acquired, you know it's most likely game over. To their credit, they survived 15 years after acquisition but barely.

show 1 reply
sleight42yesterday at 8:45 PM

Often seems like there's no defeat that Benioff can't steal from the jaws of Victory.

brightballyesterday at 9:14 PM

I remember feeling the same way about Slicehost back in the day after Rackspace acquired them. Loved Slicehost. Not too long after though, Digital Ocean appeared with everything I loved about Slicehost and has kept getting better ever since.

I feel like that's Fly.io now. They took all of the great things about Heroku but also dramatically improved and added new capabilities...while improving on pricing, particularly for lower traffic stuff. Love Fly.

show 3 replies
o_myesterday at 8:55 PM

What is there to be studied? Once a company is acquired you bounce. There is usually a two year grace period before you start feeling the pain as a customer, which should give you the time to migrate.

show 1 reply
chimeracoderyesterday at 9:28 PM

> Salesforce acquired them and just let it die, baffling.

This is a common misconception, but it's actually not true. The reality is even more bizarre.

Most of Heroku's successful years came after the acquisition, not before. Heroku was acquired extremely early in its lifecycle, and Salesforce does actually bear responsibility for investing in it and making it the powerhouse it became. Most of what people remember as the glory days of Heroku came long after the acquisition. And in fact, at the time of acquisiton, Heroku was nowhere near as competitive as a product as it later became.

It was only much later on that Salesforce began to pull the supports out from underneath it, leaving it to fall behind and become what it is today.

The narrative of "BigCo™ acquires startup, then leaves it to wither and die" is a trope because it is very commonly true, but it's actually not what happened in this particular case.

OGEnthusiastyesterday at 9:18 PM

Downfall? The founders and VCs made tens of millions of dollars. That’s the success condition for them.

pjmlpyesterday at 9:28 PM

It is a typical acquisition by the book, always goes the same way after three to five years.