logoalt Hacker News

smt88today at 7:24 AM2 repliesview on HN

> After all, the appeal of biggest cities was always, at least to me, the availability of white collar, highly paid jobs

You are definitely unusual.

Since remote work became more common because of Covid, remote workers have moved within the same city or moved to smaller cities. Only 4% relocated to rural areas[1].

Cities are appealing to most people because they have entertainment, variety, walkability, and many other benefits that rural places don't provide. The urbanization of America isn't only because work has changed, but because people generally prefer urban or suburban living over rural living.

1. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11551397/


Replies

berdariotoday at 8:08 AM

I don't think he's arguing for rural, just expressing concern about the *biggest* cities.

> entertainment, variety, walkability, and many other benefits that rural places don't provide

I appreciate all of this as well, but at the end of the day, I moved to a city with 80x the population of my hometown because of a (specific) job. Rent is also significantly higher, and if I had to consume my savings to survive here, I'd surely move out. Entertainment and walkability have secondary importance compared to putting food on the table and saving for retirement.

show 1 reply
lazidetoday at 8:03 AM

‘Smaller cities’ in the US are what most of the world calls ‘rural’.

Rural in the US is truly remote, not just ‘has farmland’.

show 1 reply