logoalt Hacker News

jazzyjacksontoday at 8:01 AM1 replyview on HN

> Ask someone to explain how riding a bicycle works, or an uneducated native speaker to explain the grammar of their language. They have no clue.

This works against your argument. Someone who can ride a bike clearly knows how to ride a bike, that they cannot express it in tokenized form speaks to the limited scope ofof written word in representing embodiment.


Replies

throw310822today at 8:31 AM

Yes and no. Riding a bicycle is a skill: your brain is trained to do the right thing and there's some basic feedback loop that keeps you in balance. You could call that a world model if you want, but it's entirely self contained, limited to a very few basic sensory signals (acceleration and balance), and it's outside your conscious knowledge. Plenty of people lack this particular "world model" and can talk about cyclists and bicycles and traffic, and whatnot.

show 1 reply