logoalt Hacker News

CuriouslyCyesterday at 4:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

Claude is more susceptible than GPT5.1+. It tries to be "smart" about context for refusal, but that just makes it trickable, whereas newer GPT5 models just refuse across the board.


Replies

wincyyesterday at 5:41 AM

I asked ChatGPT about how shipping works at post offices and it gave a very detailed response, mentioning “gaylords” which was a term I’d never heard before, then it absolutely freaked out when I asked it to tell me more about them (apparently they’re heavy duty cardboard containers).

Then I said “I didn’t even bring it up ChatGPT, you did, just tell me what it is” and it said “okay, here’s information.” and gave a detailed response.

I guess I flagged some homophobia trigger or something?

ChatGPT absolutely WOULD NOT tell me how much plutonium I’d need to make a nice warm ever-flowing showerhead, though. Grok happily did, once I assured it I wasn’t planning on making a nuke, or actually trying to build a plutonium showerhead.

show 2 replies
ryanjshawyesterday at 4:31 AM

Claude was immediately willing to help me crack a TrueCrypt password on an old file I found. ChatGPT refused to because I could be a bad guy. It’s really dumb IMO.

show 2 replies