logoalt Hacker News

jonahxyesterday at 8:17 PM1 replyview on HN

Or you can hand wave a bit and trust intuition. Just like the titans who invented it all did!

The obsession with rigor that later developed -- while necessary -- is really an "advanced topic" that shouldn't displace learning the intuition and big picture concepts. I think math up through high school should concentrate on the latter, while still being honest about the hand-waving when it happens.


Replies

andrewflnrtoday at 2:44 AM

I broadly agree. But, the big risk here is that it's really easy for an adventurous student to stretch that handwaving beyond where it's actually valid. You at least have to warn them that the "intuitions" you give them are not general methods, just explanations for why the algorithms you teach them do something worthwhile (and for the ones inclined to explore, give them some fun edge cases to think about).