logoalt Hacker News

Flood Fill vs. The Magic Circle

19 pointsby tobrlast Wednesday at 10:31 AM5 commentsview on HN

Comments

Dylan16807yesterday at 11:15 PM

This assumes very slow AI progress. I'm not one to hype up LLMs, but I would never claim it'll take 200 years before an AI can untangle a sewing machine with robot hands. Stuffing an envelope and applying a stamp? My bet is less than 20 years. That's a level of tactility that can do a tremendous amount of real-world activity. And the capability of a high end robot controlled by a human keeps expanding, so in the hypothetical "AGI" scenario the flood fill gets pretty big.

show 1 reply
Wowfunhappyyesterday at 11:53 PM

Overall, I love this essay. However, the entire argument hinges on one assertion, buried about halfway through:

> Robots are improving fast, but I do not believe that this cute fellow will be stuffing envelopes or affixing stamps anytime soon.

Is this correct? I don't know. If it's wrong... well, then there's a missing pixel in the magic circle, and flood fill will make the whole thing recognizable.

throwawaymaroonyesterday at 11:45 PM

[dead]