logoalt Hacker News

ummonkyesterday at 7:18 PM3 repliesview on HN

One of my annoyances is that most male pop singing is at too high a range for normal baritone men without vocal training to sing along. I actually find it easier to sing along to female pop songs (by singing an octave lower) than to male pop songs.


Replies

RupertSaltyesterday at 8:34 PM

If a handsome crooner with a deep voice sings sweet love songs, their fans will consist of hetero women.

If a woman sings in a high voice with a girly-girl image, she will tend to attract men.

A singer or group with great falsetto/whistle register, or female tenor/contralto, ambiguous or hetero lyrics, and androgynous image or radio-only can effectively draw in a broadly mixed-gender audience.

See new wave, synth pop, hair metal, David Bowie, Concrete Blonde, Janis Joplin, Alison Moyet, et. al.

If a performer lands on the far side of the spectrum, the producers will inevitably hire backup dancers and singers to broaden their appeal.

show 1 reply
robrtsqlyesterday at 7:48 PM

One of the great injustices of music. As a bass voice, both pop music and theater is _dominated_ by tenors (or maybe they're baritones? The point being that it seems no one wants to hear you if you can't belt a Bb4).

show 1 reply
wintermutestwinyesterday at 7:23 PM

On the Song Exploder podcast, Take on Me episode, the artist talks about the producer saying that a male falsetto was a “make this song a hit” button…

show 1 reply