alt Hacker News> C# or Java don't have this, nor can they compile C code and seamlessly interoperate with it — but in D, this is effortless.
C# C interop is pretty smooth, Java is a different story. The fact that C# is becoming the GC language in game dev is proving my point.
>Furthermore, if you dig deeper, you'll find that D offers far greater control over its garbage collector than any other high-level language, to the point that you can eagerly free chunks of allocated memory, minimizing or eliminating garbage collector stops where it matters.
Yes, and the no-gc stuff was just attempts to backpedal on the wrong initial decision to fit into the use-cases they should have targeted from the start in my opinion.
Look D was an OK language but it had no corporate backing and there was no case where it was "the only good solution". If it was an actual C++ modernization attempt that stayed C compatible it would have seen much better adoption.
Replies
> The fact that C# is becoming the GC language in game dev is proving my point.
Popularity is not proof of anything. C# is popular because it’s made by Microsoft and rode the OOP hype.
> The fact that C# is becoming the GC language in game dev is proving my point.
Respectfully, it doesn't prove your point. Unity is a commercial product that employed C# because they could sell it easily, not because it's the best language for game dev.
Godot supports C# because Microsoft sponsored the maintainers precisely on that condition.
> C# C interop is pretty smooth
True, but you still need to either generate or manually write the bindings. In D, you just import the C headers directly without depending on the bindings' maintainers.
> If it was an actual C++ modernization attempt that stayed C compatible it would have seen much better
Any D compiler is literally also a C compiler. I sincerely don't know how can one be more C compatible than that.
> Yes, and the no-gc stuff was just attempts to backpedal on the wrong initial decision
I think that it was more of an attempt to appease folks who won't use GC even with a gun to their head.