logoalt Hacker News

pilifyesterday at 3:17 PM3 repliesview on HN

On the other hand, by erroneously treating a SHOULD as a MUST, I would say that Google is the one who's not RFC-compliant


Replies

FactolSarinyesterday at 4:12 PM

Google is rejecting it to ensure incoming messages aren't spam. SHOULD means "you should do this unless you have a really, really good reason not to." Do they have a good reason not to? It doesn't seem so, meaning Viva is in the wrong here.

show 2 replies
ragallyesterday at 5:00 PM

The RFC says a SHOULD is to be treated like a MUST, but well-justified exceptions are allowed.

show 1 reply