logoalt Hacker News

I spent two days gigging at RentAHuman and didn't make a single cent

110 pointsby speckxtoday at 4:11 PM72 commentsview on HN

Comments

bkotoday at 5:20 PM

The article basically describes the user sign up, find it empty other than marketing ploys designed by humans.

It points to a bigger issue that AI has no real agency or motives. How could it? Sure if you prompt it like it was in a sci-fi novel, it will play the part (it's trained on a lot of sci-fi). But does it have its own motives? Does your calculator? No of course not

It could still be dangerous. But the whole 'alignment' angle is just a naked ploy for raising billions and amping up the importance and seriousness of their issue. It's fake. And every "concerning" study, once read carefully, is basically prompting the LLM with a sci-fi scenario and acting surprised when it has a dramatic sci-fi like response.

The first time I came across this phenomenon was when someone posted years ago how two AIs developed their own language to talk to each other. The actual study (if I remember correctly) had two AIs that shared a private key try to communicate some way while an adversary AI tried to intercept, and to no one's surprise, they developed basic private-key encryption! Quick, get Eliezer Yudkowsky on the line!

show 7 replies
snowwrestlertoday at 10:05 PM

Who needs a new app, just use DoorDash…

> Waymo is paying DoorDash gig workers to close its robotaxi doors

> The Alphabet-owned self-driving car company confirmed on Thursday that it's running a pilot in Atlanta to compensate delivery drivers for closing Waymo doors that are left ajar. DoorDash drivers are notified when a Waymo in the area has an open door so the vehicles can quickly get back on the road, the company said.

https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2026/02/12/waymo-is-paying-doordash...

neomtoday at 5:29 PM

The founder is a friend of mine, so maybe I'm bias, but I'm surprised wired doesn't get how network effects work and adoption curves happen, at least, it seems strange to publish this about a project someone did in a weekend, a few weekends ago, and is now trying to make a go of it? Like.. give him a couple of months to see how to improve the flow for the bots side, and general discoverability of the platform for agents at large. Maybe I'm a bit grumpy because it's my buddy but this article kinda rubs me the wrong way. :\

show 5 replies
mewse-hntoday at 5:22 PM

Applying for the bounty to deliver flowers and then simply not doing it seems like bad faith on the author's part in order to write that headline

show 3 replies
wongarsutoday at 4:27 PM

Note how the number advertising how many bots actually use RentAHuman has vanished from their website. Instead we now have the number of bounties. 1/40th as many as registered humans. And just scrolling through them, maybe 1/4th of the bounties are not bounties at all but more humans offering services.

It's a service that is clearly a lot more appealing to humans than to agents

show 1 reply
ge96today at 4:49 PM

Tangent

I saw this video recently where Google has people walking around carrying these backpacks (lidar/camera setup) and they map places cars can't reach. I think that's pretty interesting, maybe get data for humanoid robots too/walking through crowds/navigating alleys.

I wonder if jobs like these could be on there, walk through this neighborhood/film it kind of thing.

show 2 replies
rvztoday at 6:06 PM

This is post-AGI.

themafiatoday at 8:33 PM

RentAHuman.

What a boring misanthropy.

It's work. You're hiring qualified people. For qualified work. You're not "renting a human." Which is just an abstract idealism of chattel slavery, so, is it really a surprise the author made nothing?

show 2 replies