Reminds me of a blog post from a few days ago by Melanie Mitchell on a talk she gave about the recently-passed Brian Cantwell Smith:
Judgment, he wrote, is “a form of dispassionate deliberative thought, grounded in ethical commitment and responsible action, appropriate to the situation in which it is deployed.”
On the other hand, there is reckoning: the “calculative prowess” at which AI systems already excel. AI reckoning has lead to gold medals in mathematics competitions, to generating complex code, to predicting protein structure, and even to carrying out fluent conversations. But reckoning without judgment is a dangerous thing...
https://aiguide.substack.com/p/on-brian-cantwell-smith-and-t...