logoalt Hacker News

forrestthewoodsyesterday at 10:07 AM2 repliesview on HN

Definitely agree that Git is mediocre-at-best VCS tool. This has always been the case. But LLMs are finally forcing the issue. It’s a shame a whole generation programmers has only used Git/GitHub and think it’s good.

Monorepo and large binary file support is TheWay. A good cross-platform virtual file system (VFS) is necessary; a good open source one doesn’t exist today.

Ideally it comes with a copy-on-write system for cross-repo blob caching. But I suppose that’s optional. It lets you commit toolchains for open source projects which is a dream of mine.

Not sure I agree that LSP like features need to be built in. That feels wrong. That’s just a layer on top.

Do think that agent prompts/plans/summaries need to be a first class part of commits/merges. Not sure the full set of features required here.


Replies

JodieBenitezyesterday at 10:22 AM

> It’s a shame a whole generation programmers has only used Git/GitHub and think it’s good.

Well... I used SVN before that and it was way worse.

show 2 replies
dist-epochyesterday at 10:57 AM

> It lets you commit toolchains

Wasn't this done by IBM in the past? Rational Rose something?

show 1 reply