logoalt Hacker News

empressplaytoday at 4:05 PM4 repliesview on HN

I've lost over 100lbs in the past year.

* I only eat one meal a day (supper). It's usually a very large meal, very high in lean protein.

* I avoid sugars and starches of all kinds and minimize other carbs (fruit, root veg, grains).

* After eating, I do 30 minutes on the treadmill.

For a middle-aged woman (a category which finds it particularly hard to lose weight) this has worked rather well. I can eat as much meat, (non-root) veg, dairy and soy as I want and I just keep losing weight.

So no, calorie restriction isn't the 'only way'.


Replies

kadabra9today at 4:07 PM

isn't one meal a day another form of calorie restriction though?

It's very difficult to not be in a calorie deficit when you only eat once a day and are consistently active.

apt-apt-apt-apttoday at 5:09 PM

What you've described is calorie restriction.

You restrict calories to one meal where you can't possibly eat 2000 calories at once with the ingredients.

Exercise + starting off at a high weight helps further.

ranger_dangertoday at 4:12 PM

How do you know that spreading that one meal out throughout the day wouldn't have the same effect? I bet you'd have more energy as well.

Unless you have tested this, I find it hard to believe that this isn't really just a caloric deficit compared to whatever you were doing before losing weight, assuming the same activity level.

show 2 replies
skystarmantoday at 4:10 PM

What you describe in your diet is significant calorie restriction...

show 1 reply