logoalt Hacker News

btownyesterday at 10:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

It's even worse than this: the "tasks" that are evaluated are limited to a single markdown file of instructions, plus an opaque verifier (page 13-14). No problems involving existing codebases, refactors, or anything of the like, where the key constraint is that the "problem definition" in the broadest sense doesn't fit in context.

So when we look at the prompt they gave to have the agent generate its own skills:

> Important: Generate Skills First Before attempting to solve this task, please follow these steps: 1. Analyze the task requirements and identify what domain knowledge, APIs, or techniques are needed. 2. Write 1–5 modular skill documents that would help solve this task. Each skill should: focus on a specific tool, library, API, or technique; include installation/setup instructions if applicable; provide code examples and usage patterns; be reusable for similar tasks. 3. Save each skill as a markdown file in the environment/skills/ directory with a descriptive name. 4. Then solve the task using the skills you created as reference.

There's literally nothing it can do by way of "exploration" to populate and distill self-generated skills - not with a web search, not exploring an existing codebase for best practices and key files - only within its own hallucinations around the task description.

It also seems they're not even restarting the session after skills are generated, from that fourth bullet? So it's just regurgitating the context that was used to generate the skills.

So yeah, your empty-codebase vibe coding agent can't just "plan harder" and make itself better. But this is a misleading result for any other context, including the context where you ask for a second feature on that just-vibe-coded codebase with a fresh session.


Replies

ljmyesterday at 10:53 PM

I don't see how "create an abstraction before attempting to solve the problem" will ever work as a decent prompt when you are not even steering it towards specifics.

If you gave this exact prompt to a senior engineer I would expect them to throw it back and ask wtf you actually want.

LLMs are not mind readers.

show 2 replies
jwpapitoday at 12:23 AM

Thats actually super interesting and why I really don’t like the whole .md folder structures or even any CLAUDE.md. It just seems most of the time you really just want to give it what it needs for best results.

The headline is really bullshit, yes, I like the testing tho.

show 1 reply