> The key discovery is that there is a physiological reaction which cannot be suppressed anymore consciously.
My opposing theories are
1. dogs don't have conscious minds that are similar to humans' so the whole experiment can't be extrapolated to humans
or
2. dogs can suppress it consciously if they really want, like we can suppress the 'hanger reflex', it's just we don't have a way to tell dogs to do that
I really don't know how Pavlov experiment nullified these theories, and if it did, why "training animals to do circus tricks" didn't. Are we sure 'doing circus tricks' is equal to consciousness, and how?
alt Hacker News
The parent commenter's claim is:
> The key discovery is that there is a physiological reaction which cannot be suppressed anymore consciously.
My opposing theories are
1. dogs don't have conscious minds that are similar to humans' so the whole experiment can't be extrapolated to humans
or
2. dogs can suppress it consciously if they really want, like we can suppress the 'hanger reflex', it's just we don't have a way to tell dogs to do that
I really don't know how Pavlov experiment nullified these theories, and if it did, why "training animals to do circus tricks" didn't. Are we sure 'doing circus tricks' is equal to consciousness, and how?