logoalt Hacker News

KellyCriteriontoday at 6:39 AM2 repliesview on HN

>>The AI doesn’t know anything about the full scope of all the things in my head about my company’s environment and the information I need to convey to it.<<

This is your problem: How should it know if you do not provide it?

Use Claude - in the pro version you can submit files for each project which are setting the context: This can be files, source code, SQL scripts, screenshots whatever - then the output will be based on your context given by providing these files.


Replies

fastasucantoday at 4:31 PM

And your problem is that you didnt understood the point of their post. The full context was so complex and would be so time consuming to relay that they might as well code themselves.

dangustoday at 1:07 PM

Is this process of brain dumping faster than me just writing the code?

If I was truly going to automate this one-time task I would have to give the AI access to my browser or an API token for the repository provider, so I’m either giving it dangerous modification capability via browser automation or I’m spending even more time setting up API access and trusting that it actually knows how to interact with the service via API calls.

My company doesn’t provide Claude, they give me GitHub Copilot Pro or whatever it’s called, and when I provided the website it needed to get the RPM files I was working with it didn’t actually do anything with it. It just wrote a readme file that told me what to do. Like I mention it also just eventually mistook the remote repository as my local internal repository.

And one of the specific commands it screwed up was in my existing script and was already correct, it just decided to change it for no discernible reason. I didn’t ask it to do anything related to that particular line.

With such a high error rate, I would be hesitant to actually integrate AI to other systems to try to achieve a more fully automated workflow.