logoalt Hacker News

bzzzttoday at 1:58 PM3 repliesview on HN

Active directory is dying along with local computer networks. Microsoft is pushing customers to Entra (formerly Azure Active directory). Modern, hybrid AD is not easy to use and difficult to manage.


Replies

jabltoday at 2:47 PM

There's https://himmelblau-idm.org/ for a Linux client for Entra. Haven't tried it myself though.

show 2 replies
dijittoday at 2:53 PM

This is 100% the current situation, and it's worth mentioning because clearly you have a finger on the pulse here - and that needs to be stated for others.

But, I wonder if Microsoft might reverse their stance on EntraID being SaaS; with the handwringing about sovreignty from Europe.

Back when "the deal" was made with Microsoft to basically embed itself into the digital ecosystem of every government, major institution and company in Europe: it was not the case that a member of the european parliament could have their mail disabled arbitrarily by Microsoft- such a thing was technically possible through a lot of hoops but it was significantly less feasible.

If Microsoft was to reverse course then I'm sure it would stop all the handwringing, even if people would continue to use the EntraID product in reality.

show 1 reply
essephtoday at 2:44 PM

> dying along with local computer networks

I have seen the exact opposite, with people moving to things like jumpcloud, keycloak, authentik, etc.

show 2 replies