logoalt Hacker News

Lerctoday at 12:05 AM2 repliesview on HN

The licence?

If it comes from a site claiming it was under a licence when it was not, the misdeed is done by the person who provided the version carrying the licence.


Replies

wongarsutoday at 1:04 AM

Just because it says "CC0" does not make it CC0. If you upload a dataset you don't have the rights to, any license declaration you make is null and void, and anyone using it as if it had that license is violating copyright

Even if MS could claim that they were acting in good faith there really isn't much legal wiggle room for that. But it doesn't even come to that because I don't think anyone would buy that they really thought that the Harry Potter books were under the CC0

show 1 reply
slopinthebagtoday at 12:23 AM

Oh come on. The licence was obviously incorrect and you cant escape culpability because of that.