logoalt Hacker News

DOGE Track

260 pointsby donohoetoday at 12:13 PM144 commentsview on HN

Comments

yabonestoday at 1:54 PM

Specifically talking about USAID, that's the biggest erosion of US soft power in the country's history. All that "foreign aid" wasn't for charity or the goodness of anybody's heart, it was to keep the "3rd world" aligned with US foreign policy objectives. And to set a price floor for agricultural products.

show 10 replies
pjc50today at 1:21 PM

The sad thing is that people don't miss the administrative state until it's too late.

I'm reminded of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal ; one side effect was people importing baby formula to China from Australia, because they trusted the Australian food safety authorities more than the Chinese ones.

The DOGE gutting has most likely set up some sort of similar problem that hasn't arrived or gone public yet. Not to mention the background level of problems like the Purdue Pharma one.

show 3 replies
hamdingerstoday at 3:26 PM

The true purpose of DOGE was to exfiltrate sensitive data from the IRS, SSA, Medicaid, and other agencies. We may never know what all they have done/are doing with it, but it's certainly playing a role in the current immigration crackdowns.

Long term it will affect us all, likely more than the cuts the news prefers to focus on (tragic though they may be).

show 1 reply
plasma_beamtoday at 2:13 PM

I like the layout of this site. However I feel it should be stated more prominently that the primary source of data are online news articles.

aaa_aaatoday at 2:03 PM

To me improving "government efficieny" is unattainable for large states. Who claims to achieve this is a fool or a bad actor.

show 6 replies
youknownothingtoday at 4:17 PM

Putting everything that DOGE has done, am I the only one who thinks that there is a teeny, tiny conflict of interest in Musk naming a department pretty much the same as one of the cryptocurrencies that he supports (Dogecoin)? Isn't that using the government for marketing?

show 2 replies
squeegmeistertoday at 3:47 PM

You might consider sharing this in the fednews subreddit. Awesome project

dlev_pikatoday at 5:01 PM

One of the lessons of this Trump administration is that we *can* affect radical change, if the will is there.

I truly hope our future DSA gov takes this experience to heart.

baggachipztoday at 3:09 PM

Oh great, I was really hoping to get my blood boiling today. Reading about data breaches done in the light of day is appalling, infinitely more so when it's condoned by the government who's supposed to prevent such grift and violations of privacy. It will take a long time to recover from this insane timeline (if ever).

myrmidontoday at 2:15 PM

I think it is really important from time to time to shed partisan tendencies and critically review policy initiatives and form a somewhat subjective overpromise/underdeliver judgement (also looking at where, why and how they succeeded or failed).

To me, the whole Doge initiative scores quite poorly in this regard: Initial promises appear not realistic (or even worse: deceptive), while the (preliminary) results are lackluster, too.

My impression is that the vast majority of "savings" was never achieved by promised efficiency gains or elimination of pure waste, but instead simply by cutting projects, i.e. slashing some form of public service or benefit in order to save tax money. Which is obviously inferior.

I think promises along that exact line deserve extreme skepticism: "Simply" slashing regulations/public budget for "easy gains" is just not credible, and if anyone is gonna bring up the same arguments in favor of nuclear power or similar things I'm just gonna label them "liar/idiot" and watch reality endorse my view...

show 4 replies
FrustratedMonkytoday at 2:10 PM

This site is great.

But needs some overall graphic, some charts or something, to tell a story. Something like dollars spent versus saved, to show how this whole effort was in-efficient.

And. I'd like to see something similar for Project 2025.

show 3 replies
kyle_martin1today at 4:05 PM

[dead]

dfilppitoday at 4:38 PM

[dead]

spiderfarmertoday at 12:48 PM

[flagged]

show 5 replies
jazz9ktoday at 1:17 PM

[flagged]

show 2 replies
reenoraptoday at 3:05 PM

The complete lack of wanting to rein in federal spending by some people is mind boggling to me. The number of employees in some departments of the government almost doubled in 5 years, with nothing to show except a huge budget.

show 10 replies