alt Hacker NewsThis is Nice.
However, how do one access their diary, when you stopped maintaining it? Is this targeted more at the technically inclined, high-profile people who need to keep secrets?
Personally, I believe that for something like a diary/journal, it should be in a format easily readable by most tools (so a Plain-Text or a MarkDown at best), then it is in a container/folder. Now, encrypt that container/folder instead. In the future, when you need to change the tool for Encryption/Decryption, move the container/folder.
For instance, tools such as https://cryptomator.org comes to mind.
Replies
I think there are two different concerns mixed together:
1) Can I still read my data in 10 years? That’s mostly about open, well-documented formats + an export path. A journaling app can still be “safe” here if it can export to Markdown/plain-text (or at least JSON) and the on-disk schema is documented.
2) Can I decrypt it in 10 years? That’s about using boring primitives (AES-GCM, Argon2/scrypt/PBKDF2) and keeping the crypto layer simple. If it’s standard crypto, you’re not locked to one vendor the way you might be with a bespoke format.
The “plain files in an encrypted folder” approach (Cryptomator/VeraCrypt) is totally reasonable—and arguably the simplest threat model—but you do give up a lot of what makes a journal app nice (full-text search, tags, structured metadata, conflict handling, etc.). SQLite + client-side encryption is a fine compromise if there’s a solid export and the KDF/password story is strong.
The biggest real risk is still: losing the password. A printable recovery key / key export would help more than switching formats.
yeah, currently you can export your journal to json or markdown files. So you can walk away at any point. Vendor lock-in is one of the main things i wanted to avoid. That's why I sticked with boring and standard libraries and encryption as much as possible. Thanks for the feedback!
When I had a Mac I used an encrypted volume in Dropbox. (Not sure if that's a good idea, but I didn't have any issues.)
I used Notational Velocity in those days :) A rare gem of ergonomics.
Later I did the same thing with a VeraCrypt volume.
Now I'm in Obsidian, which has its own encryption (if you trust 'em!), but never quite got the frictionless feeling of NV back.