logoalt Hacker News

neither_colortoday at 4:31 AM3 repliesview on HN

It's not just about language. There's no common practical path to becoming "Chinese", either in a legal or cultural sense. Save for a few rare exceptions, you cannot move there, join the culture, become a citizen, etc even if you're fluent. The western systems arent perfect but they allow a greater number of people who really want to assimilate do so regardless of background.


Replies

entropyneurtoday at 10:01 AM

Why would anyone want to become a Chinese citizen? How's everyone discussing linguistics while completely ignoring the authoritarian elephant in the room?

show 2 replies
chickenbigtoday at 8:51 AM

> regardless of background

I seem to recall that is a problem with Switzerland too; people can be refused citizenship by bureaucracy at the local level. Yet people still flock there (perhaps because of the money).

show 1 reply
FooBarWidgettoday at 6:25 AM

You can by marrying a Chineze citizen. It won't make you a citizen, but you can get long term residence permit, and your children will be Chinese citizen.

They don't do naturalisation of foreigners, that's true. You can only give that to your children.