logoalt Hacker News

Barbingyesterday at 5:01 PM1 replyview on HN

>anyone else

Perhaps not other thought leaders.

I would be curious to know:

How many clicks out from HN, and much time on page on average (on his site), and much subsequent pro-social discussion on HN, did those links generate versus the average linkout here? Wouldn’t change the rules but I do suspect[0] it would repaint self-promotion as something more genuine.


Replies

bakugoyesterday at 6:18 PM

> Perhaps not other thought leaders.

Nice way of saying grifters.

You're bringing up essentially the same non-argument that dang himself used when he recently personally told off someone else for pointing out the same rule breaking behavior. It boils down to "People upvote it and comment on it so it must be good content regardless of which rules it breaks" which is a harmful way of thinking, the social media version of "laws are only for the poor".

If getting enough upvotes and replies elevates one above the rules, it should be clearly stated in said rules, but I have a feeling it never will be because it's obviously not a good look.