logoalt Hacker News

yodsanklaiyesterday at 10:58 PM6 repliesview on HN

Because code isn't free.

I can see it in my team. We've all been using Claude a lot for the last 6 months. It's hard to measure the impact, but I can tell our systems are as buggy as ever. AI isn't a silver bullet.


Replies

reconnectingyesterday at 11:19 PM

And after 12 months, most probably no one from your team will understand what the result of half of those bugs is.

When devs outsource their thinking to AI, they lose the mental map, and without it, control over the entire system.

show 8 replies
XenophileJKOyesterday at 11:37 PM

I love the fact that we just got a model really capable of doing sustained coding (let me check my notes here...) 3 months ago, with a significant bump 15 days ago.

And now the comments are "If it is so great why isn't everything already written from scratch with it?"

show 3 replies
AceJohnny2today at 12:45 AM

I'm reminded of the viral comic "I'm stupid faster" (2019?) by Shen

https://imgur.com/gallery/i-m-stupid-faster-u8crXcq

(sorry for Imgur link, but Shen's web presence is a mess and it's hard to find a canonical source)

I'm not saying this is completely the case for AI coding agents, whose capabilities and trustworthiness have seen a meteoric rise in the past year.

OsrsNeedsf2Pyesterday at 11:04 PM

Why isn't Claude doing QA testing for you?

show 2 replies
neal_jonesyesterday at 11:33 PM

Dude, I blame all bugs on ai at this point. I suspect one could roughly identify AI’s entry into the game based on some metric of large system outages. Assume someone has already done this but…probably doesn’t matter.