logoalt Hacker News

selridgeyesterday at 11:29 PM5 repliesview on HN

Presumably these competent people could look at electron, think about building their own cross-platform application on top of chromium and conclude that this free as in code and beer tool fit their needs.

Should they have re-written Chromium too?


Replies

misiryesterday at 11:51 PM

They don't have to reinvent electron. They shouldn't need to use a whole virtualized operating system to call their web API with a fancy UI.

Projects with much smaller budget than Atrophic has achieved much better x-plat UI without relying on electron [1]. There are more sensible options like Qt and whatnot for rendering UIs.

You can even engineer your app to have a single core with all the business logic as a single shared library. Then write UI wrappers using SwiftUI, GTK, and whatever microsoft feels like putting out as current UI library (I think currently it's WinUI2) consuming the core to do the interesting bits.

Heck there are people whom built gui toolkits from scratch to support their own needs [2].

[1] - https://musescore.org/en [2] - https://www.gpui.rs

show 1 reply
hackingonemptytoday at 12:00 AM

They have the resources to make native UI for all six major platforms without any AI assistance at all.

Maybe their dog food isn't as tasty as they want you to believe.

PacificSpecificyesterday at 11:43 PM

There's other ways to make cross platforms apps than to build them on top of a web browser

show 1 reply
LtWorftoday at 12:22 AM

You are unfamiliar with native toolkits?

show 1 reply
rustystumpyesterday at 11:31 PM

Bun exists and building a ui on too of that should be well within the power of the money they have. No one is saying to rebuild the universe but the current state is embarrassing.

show 1 reply