logoalt Hacker News

kelipsoyesterday at 10:29 PM2 repliesview on HN

If it’s not trained to be biased towards Elon Musk is always right or whatever, I think it will be much less of a problem than humans.

Humans are VERY political creatures. A hint that their side thinks X is true and humans will reorganize their entire philosophy and worldview retroactively to rationalize X.

LLMs don’t have such instincts and can potentially be instructed to present or evaluate the primary, if opposing, arguments. So you architecturally predisposed argument, I don’t think is true.


Replies

woodruffwyesterday at 11:13 PM

> LLMs don’t have such instincts and can potentially be instructed to present or evaluate the primary, if opposing, arguments.

It seems essentially wrong to anthropomorphize LLMs as having instincts or not. What they have is training, and there's currently no widely accepted test for determining whether a "fair" evaluation from an LLM stems from biases during training.

(It should be clear that humans don't need to be unpolitical; what they need to be is accountable. Wikipedia appears to be at least passably competent at making its human editors accountable to each other.)

show 1 reply
Rebelgeckoyesterday at 10:32 PM

There was a whole collection of posts where Grok says stuff like "Elon Musk is more athletic than LeBron James".

show 1 reply