logoalt Hacker News

bob001today at 2:44 AM1 replyview on HN

The peer review process provides a minimal level of verification, and the paper provides details that can be directly looked at.


Replies

qseratoday at 7:20 AM

>The peer review process provides a minimal level of verification

But this is only true if you trust the peer more than the author. Because both the author and the peer are not accountable to you or to mostly none.

So "peer review", without any other qualification is as good as shit.

Every time I see people go "BUT IS IT PEER REVIEWED !??" I can't help but chuckle.