logoalt Hacker News

ddp26today at 1:35 AM2 repliesview on HN

I tried using wolfram alpha as a tool for an llm research agent, and I couldn't find any tasks it could solve with it, that it couldn't solve with just Google and Python.


Replies

snowhaletoday at 4:02 AM

the tasks where wolfram actually outperforms python+google are symbolic: exact algebraic simplification, closed-form integrals, formal power series, equation solving over specific domains. for numeric work you're right that python wins. but for cases where you need a guarantee that x^2-1 = (x+1)(x-1) and not a floating-point approximation of it, wolfram is in a different category. the question is whether LLMs are running into those cases often enough to justify the overhead.

show 1 reply
nradovtoday at 2:58 AM

Well sure, in theory any mathematical problem can be solved with any Turing complete programming language. I think the idea here is that for certain problem domains Mathematica might be more efficient or easier for humans to understand than Python.